Dallas Cowboys Draft: Perception VS Reality

How fans perceive the Dallas Cowboys draft track record is far different from reality. * Photo by rchdj10 https://www.flickr.com/photos/rchdj10/

The NFL draft is only a few hours away and this year promises to be one of the more unpredictable and exciting drafts in many years. No one really knows what to expect but one thing is for sure; whoever the Dallas Cowboys draft in the first round of the 2022 NFL draft is sure to be criticized by a large portion of the fanbase. This seems to be the case no matter how high profile or talented the player is. Even if they draft a player like CeeDee Lamb, who no one dreamed would have fallen to pick #17 in the 2020 draft, there are going to be fans that complain about positions of need. Last year, fans were up on arms when the Cowboys drafted an off-ball linebacker named Micah Parsons only to eat their words when he was voted the unanimous Defensive Rookie of the Year and was even in contention for Defensive Player of the Year honours in his rookie season. Still, the very next year the same cynical fans will doubt the ability of the front office to make a competent selection with their first round pick. It is becoming exceedingly rare that a Cowboys draft pick is widely celebrated by the majority of the fanbase. That will likely be the case again For the 2022 NFL draft. This year, more than 2000 fans were surveyed in a study conducted by USBets.com and the Dallas Cowboys were voted 1 of 5 teams most likely to fumble their draft pick.

The other teams in the top 5 are the Cleveland Browns, New York Jets, Detroit Lions, and Chicago Bears; Not exactly great company to keep. The Dallas Cowboys are the only NFC East team included in that lot and that doesn’t seem to paint a very accurate picture of reality. Here is comparison of first round picks for all of the NFC East teams since 2010:

DALLAS COWBOYSNEW YORK GIANTSWASHINGTON COMMANDERSPHILADELPHIA EAGLES
2010Dez Bryant, WRJason Pierre Paul, DETrent Williams, OTBrandon Graham, DE
2011Tyron Smith, OTPrince Amukumara, CBRyan Kerrigan, DEDanny Watkins, G
2012Maurice Claiborne, CBDavid Wilson, RBRobert Griffin III, QBFletcher Cox, DT
2013Travis Frederick, CJustin Pugh, OTNO PICKLane Johnson, OT
2014Zack Martin, GOdell Beckham Jr, WRNO PICKMarcus Smith, LB
2015Byron Jones, CBEreck Flowers, OTBrandon Scherff, OTNelson Agholor, WR
2016Ezekiel Elliott, RBEli Apple, CBJosh Doctson, WRCarson Wentz, QB
2017Taco Charlton, DEEvan Engram, TEJonathan Allen, DTDerek Barnett, DE
2018Leighton Vander Esch, LBSaquan Barkley, RBDarron Payne, DTNO PICK
2019NO PICKDaniel Jones, QB
Dexter Lawrence, DT
Dwayne Haskins, QB
Montez Sweat, DE
Andre Dillard, OT
2020CeeDee Lamb, WRAndrew Thomas, OTChase Young, DEJalen Reagor, WR
2021Micah Parsons, LBKadarius Toney, WRJamin Davis, LBDevonta Smith, WR

The Cowboys track record actually looks pretty good compared to their division rivals. To be completely fair, they have been one of the better teams in the league when it comes to drafting players recently, particularly in the first round. So how can this widespread cynicism be explained? Perhaps these fans are simply being prejudiced by the Dallas Cowboys recent championship drought and their lack of playoff success since the dynasty years of the 90’s. It could be spawned from the general disdain Cowboy fans have towards their teams’ outspoken billionaire owner/GM Jerry Jones. Or maybe the new public enemy number one in Dallas, Jerry’s son Stephen Jones. Stephen has adopted the nick name “cap boy” because of his reluctance to spend money in free agency and to drag out contract negotiations. Even Jerry has gotten on board with the Stephen hate as he threw his son under the bus recently blaming him for the Taco Charlton pick (one of the few misses they have had in recent years) while taking credit for selecting Micah Parsons. Whatever the reason for this belief, the fact remains that the fanbase doesn’t have a whole lot of faith in the organization and whoever the Dallas Cowboys draft tonight is unlikely to be the peoples’ choice.

Author

  • Cowboys Coffee Talk is an editorial blog that I aim to use as a platform to share my opinions about the Dallas cowboys past and present. I invite you to please read, enjoy and feel free to share your opinions as well.

    View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *