Dallas Cowboys roster cuts: Final Thoughts

The Dallas Cowboys cutting All-Pro kicker Dan Bailey (#5 above) was one of several surprise roster decisions.
*Photo by Kieth Allison https://www.flickr.com/photos/keithallison

The Dallas Cowboys roster cuts have been completed and a few waiver wire additions have been added.  Injured players Travis Frederick (C), Datone Jones (DT) and Noah Brown (WR) remain on the roster  but  Brown is expected to be placed on IR and Deonte Thompson (WR) recalled.  Here is a look at the current 53 man roster for the silver and blue for 2018:

QuarterbackDak PrescottCooper Rush
Mike White
Running BackEzekiel ElliottRod Smith
Jamize Olawale
Wide ReceiverCole Beasley
Allen Hurns
Michael Gallup
Terrance Williams
Tavon Austin
Noah Brown
Tight EndGeoff SwaimBlake Jarwin
Dalton Shultz
Rico Gathers
Offensive LineTyron Smith
Connor Williams
Joe Looney
Zack Martin
La'el Collins
Travis Frederick
Cameron Irving
Adam Redmond
Parker Eihnger
Defensive LineDeMarcus Lawrence
Antwuan Woods
Tyrone Crawford
Randy Gregory
Maliek Collins
Datone Jones
Taco Charlton
Dorance Armstrong
Daniel Ross
LinebackerSean Lee
Jaylon Smith
Damien Wilson
Leighton Vander Esch
Joe Thomas
Justin March-Lillard
Chris Covington
Defensive BackByron Jones
Xavier Woods
Jeff Heath
Chidobe Awuzie
Kavon Frazier
Jourdan Lewis
Anthony Brown
Ibraheim Campbell
Tyree Robinson
Special TeamsBrett Maher (K)
Chris Jones (P)
L.P Ladouceur (LS)

There is more than a few surprises at how the final roster has been put together thus far.  The Cowboys went thin at RB, WR and CB while they kept 3 QB’s, 4 TE’s and loaded up on DL, OL and LB.  The deepest position group is linebacker and the weakest in terms of quality is safety.

The most shocking roster decision was the release of the NFL’s All-time 2nd most accurate kicker Dan Bailey in favour of rookie Brett Maher.  The Cowboys will save about $3 million with this move but will sacrifice a proven kicker with experience, who has made game winning kicks before.  The money may have been the primary motivation for Bailey’s release or it may be that the Cowboys lost confidence in him following his 2017 struggles.  Either way, it is was an unexpected move that comes with great risk.  Jason Garrett constantly preaches that he wants the “right kind of guys” on his team, yet he cuts a team captain like Dan Bailey while keeping guys like David Irving, Randy Gregory and now Rico Gathers.  There is no doubt there exists a culture of tolerance for lack of discipline on the Dallas Cowboys.  No wonder the Cowboys lead the league in games lost to suspension during the Jason Garrett’s era. (see below)

 

I was among many fans hoping that the Cowboys would keep Rico Gathers on the roster despite his inability to block.  I was hoping that they would get creative and find a way to use his unique skill set as a red zone weapon.  I did not expect the Cowboys to keep him on the team though, even before he was arrested on Friday.  It was not a wise decision on Gather’s part to be arrested for possession of marijuana the day before roster cuts.  This was at a time he was considered on the roster bubble.  It does not bode well for Gather’s maturity and motivation to succeed.  Despite this indiscretion, and as of September 1st, Rico Gathers remains on the Dallas Cowboys 53 man roster.

Defensive End is a position loaded with depth and talent.  The addition of Randy Gregory has given the Dallas Cowboys faithful the belief that our pass rush can be dominant.  If Gregory can stay clean and avoid any trouble then all signs indicate that could be the case.  Unfortunately, All it will take is one mistake and the Cowboys will regret giving Gregory another chance while cutting players like Kony Ealy and Charles Tapper.  Luckily, the Cowboys were fortunate enough to be able to secure the oft injured Tapper to the practice squad in case his services are required.

The Cowboys addressed their depth concerns at OL and safety via the waiver wire process adding Ibraheim Campbell (S) and Adam Redmond (C/G).  But, while the starting OL still looks solid, safety is still a disaster.  At offensive line, Cowboy fans can breathe a sigh of relief that Chaz Green is gone for good but the new swing tackle Cameron Flemming has not looked all that great as his replacement.  With regards to the safety position, Cowboy fans are still waiting for an Earl Thomas trade to save their secondary.  Unfortunately, that may not be in the cards.  Sadly, anything short of adding Thomas really has me worried about the back end of this defense for this season.

There is the great concern among the fan base about the backup QB situation.  Neither Cooper Rush or Mike White have looked great in the preseason playing behind the Cowboys brutal second string OL.  The Cowboys have opted not to bring in an experienced veteran and to ride it out with the young guys.  If Dak Prescott stays healthy then there is nothing to worry about.  If Dak does get hurt, then the Cowboys could be in for a repeat of the 4–12 2015 season, even if they do bring in veteran QB at that point.

Overall, I am happy with this roster and optimistic about the Cowboys chances for success in 2018.  The success of the offense is contingent on the health of the Offensive Line starters, Ezekiel Elliott and Dak Prescott.  On the defensive side of the ball, the depth on the front seven and the potential for a solid pass rush will hopefully make up for the major weakness at safety and the lack of a dominant run stopping presence on the interior defensive line.

 

*Photo by Kieth Allison https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/legalcode